Expert panels do not always agree. In one of our files, five experts reported: three found no similarity between the marks and two filed a dissenting report. That split meant that seven experts had to be elected.
The party planned first to ask the court to disregard the five-expert report because of its internal contradictions. If the court agreed, it could appoint five new experts or go to seven.
It did not go that way in the file. A new judge refused both a request that the five experts add a supplementary report to explain their contradictory opinions, and a request for seven experts. The judge then closed the pleadings and set a date for the decision.
This is one file only, but it shows that a split panel does not automatically produce a larger one: in that file the new judge refused both requests.
If your five-expert panel splits:
- Look at whether the report is internally contradictory
- Consider asking the court to disregard it, so that five new experts or seven can be appointed
- Ask for a supplementary report only if you are ready for the judge to refuse
Dealing with a divided expert report in Iraq? Our Baghdad team can assess the next move with you.