Under Court of Cassation precedents, trademark disputes are treated as technical matters, so judges rely substantially on court-appointed experts.
A party adversely affected by a three-expert report may request five experts, but the judge keeps discretion to consider the expert evidence adequate and refuse a larger panel at any stage. In one file the judge refused seven experts when the five-expert panel had reached the same conclusion as the three.
A refusal is not necessarily the end. In one infringement case we objected formally to the three-expert report and requested five experts; the request was rejected in the same session. When the judge relies on the three-expert report, a judgment is issued and it can be challenged before the Court of Cassation, affirming the right to request five experts. In another file the Court of Cassation found the rejection correct, because the court was satisfied from the report that there was no similarity, and its decision was final.
If the judge may refuse a larger panel:
- Record the objection and the request for five experts formally at the hearing
- Expect the court to review the successive reports before judgment
- Keep the Court of Cassation route open after judgment
Facing a three-expert report you disagree with? Our Baghdad team can plan the objection with you.