In both the civil and the criminal route, the Iraqi judge will require two witnesses to appear, submit purchase receipts issued by the defendant's establishment and confirm that they bought the counterfeit goods from the defendant. Witnesses are usually presented when the judge asks for them, most likely at the third hearing. In one Kurdistan case the judge asked for witnesses at the first hearing, and in one Baghdad case the judge dispensed with witnesses and appointed experts instead.
In Baghdad the witness appears before the judge, presents a sample of the counterfeit goods with a purchase receipt in his own name, testifies that he bought them from the defendant and takes the oath. In Kurdistan the witness is both witness and expert: under oath the judge asks questions that need market expertise, such as whether the goods can be told apart, whether the counterfeit has affected the original goods and how the two marks are similar. An ordinary person cannot answer them.
Finding witnesses is the principal difficulty, because they fear retaliation. We do not arrange or provide witnesses ourselves; it is customary for the instructing party to identify them in coordination with its exclusive agent in Iraq.
To prepare witnesses for an Iraqi infringement case:
- Have two employees of the exclusive distributor buy the goods, with receipts in their own names showing the purchased mark
- In one Kurdistan file the witnesses were to bring identification, two samples of the counterfeit goods, two samples of the genuine goods and the receipts
- In one Kurdistan case witnesses were requested at the first hearing, so be ready early there
Thinking of acting against a counterfeiter in Iraq? Talk to our team about who should testify before the first hearing.